In an age of television comedy that can truly be considered golden (
Parks and Recreation,
Louie,
30 Rock,
Happy Endings,
Cougar Town, and literally on and on), the bar is understandably set high. A year or ten ago, a current hit like
Modern Family would have been groundbreaking, not only as comedy but as television in general. Today's great TV comedies offer worlds with such great depth (think Pawnee, or the wide eyed curiosity with which Louis C.K. sees the world on
Louie) and characters that constantly evolve (think Jeff Winger, or any number of
Community characters). So when something like
Modern Family embraces its role as a product sold by The ABC Manufacturing Network Inc. and over the years stays exactly as consumers seem to want, those who have come to know and love depth and evolution will understandably start to turn on it.
In comes Fox's "New Girl", a show whose very title might suggest beyond its literal meaning that whatever it is you're about to see, it's anything but stale. Is it? In some ways yes, and some ways no. On the one hand, it's perhaps the boldest show on television in how willing it is to take risks that have a fairly middling rate of success. But when those risks don't pay off, it's not much more than high brow slapstick, if such a concept is plausible.